Summary:

1. Stats

1. His stats change beyond the expected variance round to round on occasion

2. After a 5 month break and just a few terrible rounds that could be expected, he rebounds to several winning rounds with an accuracy from ~10% to 44%.

3. 2 months ago, after his ~50 rounds with 37-41% average accuracy, he drops to 20% and below average accuracy for ~180 (spreadsheet row 340) rounds

4. After very many rounds and an average accuracy at 20% or lower, with his ban being lifted, his accuracy is back at 29% (12 round average) close to where it was before he took his 8 month break.

5. After his successful ban appeal, his accuracy actually increases a bit, to a 50 round average of 27%. Much higher than his over 100 matches at under 20% average accuracy

II. Video evidence (inspect at 0.25 speed)

1. Almost all of his revolver/pistol kills are on the first shot. EDIT: (7/10) -

2. Many of the auto kills are also with the first shot, almost all are within 3 shots.

3. His revolver kills and both railgun kills snap to center of mass as he fires EDIT: I realize this could be a spectator glitch, but I have never seen it before.

4. Railgun headshot on a moving target with a snap ahead of target as it fires

Each of these points and kills might be dismissed as luck or glitches, or as circumstantial evidence. However, combined, they provide a preponderance of evidence of OscyJack using an Aimbot.

https://bf4db.com/player/354858177

Has been reported clean, here is more evidence.

I suspect OscyJack of an Aimbot.

His appeal thread: https://bf4db.com/forum/thread/ban-appeal-oscyjack-42

I would like to make a case that involves both statistics and video proof. Together I believe there is enough proof of an aimbot for the initial ban will be reinstated. As the initial ban was based on only a few pulled battlereports, I pulled all of them to compare them.

As my entire report is too long here is a pastbin, and a google doc link OscyJack's Report 

Here is the stats link: details in the paste bin

Here is the video link: Details are both in the paste bin and the video description