Hang on.... It might seem a bit far fetched but he could be faking it so that it will seem as if the banned account is playing with his smurf accounts so that it seems like it's another person rather than himself... I'm sorry but is it not suspicious already that he immediately starts playing together with his smurf accounts DURING the appeal and NOT before? Seems strange to me and I'm certain it looks strange to you Scavenger.

If I don't know what you typed then the admins won't know either... Please rephrase or talk in your native language as there may be some admins who can assist you better

Admins would require a battle report which shows that your account and another account in order to prove your innocence.. This is the only proof they require to show you're telling the truth as seen from previous appeals from other similar cases